Kaleigh compared the Luminous Dewy Skin Mist to the True Match Lumi Shake and Glow Dew Mist. Here's what they had to say:
Tatcha Luminous Dewy Skin Mist comes with 1.35oz of product for $48 while L'Oreal Shake and Glow Dew Mist comes with 3.0 oz of product for $11.99. The fist noticeable difference in this product was the packaging. Tatcha comes in a very elaborate box with a cloth pull tab with the glass bottle housed inside. L'Oreal on the other hand comes as is in the plastic bottle. Both products have a pump-spray applicator and distribute the product in a light an even manner. The products are also different colors. Tatcha has a milky white slightly thicker formula that dries transparent when applied to the skin. L'Oreal is a transparent thinner formula that also dries transparent when applied. Both products have a nice fragrance that is also slightly different. I would describe Tatcha as a warmer scent while L'Oreal is more flowery. Both scents are mild and appealing. When testing this product I tested it both applied to the entire face with and without makeup and also as my moistening agent on my beauty blender when baking and applying powder setting products. When applied to the skin both with and without makeup I found no difference in the two products. I was really impressed with the sheen of L'oreal and its hydrating effects. I also found that its durability was just as good as Tatcha throughout the day. The biggest difference I noticed between the two was when I used it as my ‘water’ base on a beauty blender. I actually found that L'Oreal outperformed Tatcha! Tatcha left some of my setting powders a little tackier and would on occasion leave a powder with small clumps. L'Oreal did not have this effect at all and was an awesome base leaving the product even and smooth. I 120% recommend purchasing L'Oreal if you are looking for a Tatcha dupe! *It should be noted that Tatcha is considered 'Clean at Sephora' and has an EWG score of 5. L'Oreal does not claim to be clean.
Want more? Download the free Brandefy App to get access to ingredient matches, comparison images, and hundreds of other beauty comparisons written by our community members!
