Carolyne compared the All Nighter Setting Spray to the Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist. Here's what they had to say:
We have the very loved and favorited Urban Decay setting spray for $33 with 4.0 fl oz vs. the new e.l.f Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist for $10 with 2.7 fl oz. I have loved and stayed true to my UD for years; your makeup does last all day with minimal movement, it doesn’t have a bad smell to it, and the mist that comes out is perfect! Now, the new e.l.f setting mist does have a hint of a cucumber smell (for me it’s like a spa smell). It helps grip your makeup, helps it last all day, and doesn’t separate your makeup. With that being said, both setting mists are very much alike in wear time, I don’t mind the smell on either, and they get the job done! Differences are that the sprayer on UD is more consistent, whereas, the e.l.f does sometimes fail. Also e.l.f has like a metal ball inside to help the product mix as you shake the bottle by helping to break up and shake up the product. For me, I’ll save some coin and just pour my e.l.f product in the empty UD bottle to ensure my mist is consistent. I also find the e.l.f mist very soothing for my skin (maybe due to the cucumber). Enjoy beauties!
Want more? Download the free Brandefy App to get access to ingredient matches, comparison images, and hundreds of other beauty comparisons written by our community members!
